Page 2 of 3

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 28 May 2012, 16:32
by daveh
Hi John,

My vote would be for a Buccaneer and a Gannet, although the double props might be a bit of an animation challenge on the latter. Any rotor craft would also be very welcome.

Dave

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 28 May 2012, 18:00
by Bora
Being a huge fan of retro traffic from the years 1985-1990 the Bucaneer would be my absolute favorite !! A Canberra would also be great...

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 28 May 2012, 18:18
by Firebird
One that I had forgotten about but would definitely fit the bill would be the Nimrod. All 3 versions.

Before anybody says it, I know about the UKMIL ones, but I don't won't to go over old ground about those models.
Without belittling somebody elses efforts I would really appreciate new models.

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 28 May 2012, 18:19
by John Young
Many thanks for the suggestions so far. I've also corresponded with Mike P and I now know what to avoid to prevent duplication, particularly in FS9. I'll dump the UK Phantom idea. I was only really inspired because I happened to come across the War Paint book at the Yeovilton FAA Museum at the weekend when taking a break while travelling back from Cornwall. More importantly, I've seen more of what Mike is doing with the UK F-4s, not to mention the Migs and the scope is just mind boggling.

V-Force and Bucanneer are certainly possibilities based on the responses so far, but no one has mentioned USAF retro, like the B-29, B-36 or B-47. Having narrowed the can of worms a tad, I know that might open it up again, but I am keen to spend time on something users actually want and isn't available elsewhere. It would be nice also if some scenery existed in which to operate the aircraft.

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 28 May 2012, 18:49
by Firebird
I admit that I was concentrating purely on Brit builds but if you were doing American builds then the F-100 and F-101 would be good canditates. Both were based in the UK.

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 28 May 2012, 19:02
by f4nutter
take a rain check on the F-100 :wink:

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 28 May 2012, 19:05
by bismarck
John, if you want to re-open it, including other air forces and going back to the WWII era.... I think the "wishlist" will never ends :smt003 .
I love the Superfortress :smt007 , but what about the Blackbird? :smt055 :smt055 :smt055
And the P-38? Mosquito, Zero, Me-262, 109, 190, Tempest, Macchi 202?

Ok stop, at least for me. :smt003

Giorgio

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 28 May 2012, 19:32
by petebramley
Not even retro and I know it was being built by someone but not heard
anything for quite some time, BUFF anyone ??

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 28 May 2012, 20:19
by delbydoo
John you really are brave doing something like this but I'll chuck my two pence worth in and how about a bit of a compromise on the US/UK retro scene - the AV-8A! I'm surprised nobody has mentioned the poor little Harrier, in AV-8A, GR1, GR3, SHAR 1 & 2 and GR5 guises? Otherwise, Buccaneer sounds REALLY good and would fit in nicely with, say a nice retro setup for the Navy at Lossie back in the 1970s, or Honington during the 80s :D You know, just saying like..... :lol:

EDIT: I am also in full agreement with Steve on the Nimrod thingy....which probably doesn't help does it? :roll:

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 28 May 2012, 20:59
by james84
Well, if the theme is "RAF Cold War" one should add the TSR.1 too!

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 28 May 2012, 21:16
by timbob1
Love your aircraft so far John, definately a Vulcan, Victor tanker and several variants of the Andover.

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 28 May 2012, 22:37
by Garysb
John
The Canberra is still in service today sort of Nasa?
Loads of versions + B-57

Gary

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 28 May 2012, 23:16
by Makadocias
Isn't it an idea to make a poll so people can vote which model they would love to see most? :smt001

In the end you should make what you want but this might help?

Thanks in advance for whatever you will make! :D

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 29 May 2012, 00:56
by Jon
Canberra. Just look to the left :wink:

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 29 May 2012, 02:01
by Joecoastie
Does any one remember the B-45 ? Really retro.

Image

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 29 May 2012, 02:21
by btaylo24
B-52!!!! Really need one.. :D

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 29 May 2012, 03:12
by sr01
John
If you're still playing requests
How about a GOOD F104 ?
and an F101

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 29 May 2012, 04:46
by Chrisb
John,

All of the above please.

Bottom line is.....whatever you enjoy making as we will no doubt enjoy having it.

Chris

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 29 May 2012, 06:10
by John Young
Right, time to draw a line under this I think.

Interestingly, there is a wish list poll for AI aircraft over at the Owl's Nest. It has some really diverse results though, the top 5 being:

B-52 (302 votes)
Fiat G-91 (204 votes)
B-36 (165 votes)
F-84 (152 votes)
V-22 Osprey (150 votes)

I'm not a great lover of online polls because the results can often be distrorted by repeat voting. I'd rather like to see some qualitative comment as we have in this thread.

So, on that basis, my top 4 would appear to be:

Vulcan/Victor/Valient (6 mentions)
Buccaneer (5 mentions)
Canberra (4 mentions)
Sea Vixen (3 mentions)

All of those appeal to me and I may make them all yet. I think I'm going to start with some Victors and Canberras. They will fit in niceley with my Marham scenery if I regressed it a bit.

Thanks everyone for your input.

John

Re: What to make next?

Posted: 29 May 2012, 07:03
by delbydoo
Thanks for your time John and look forward to whatever comes our way :)